All posts by Jason Rodgers

Against the Poverty of Language and Thought: Defending Ambiguous Situations

Cell phones are an overpowering, ever-present factor in society. A factor which has multiplied at a staggering rate.

They help to deal with the fear of the unknown. Supposedly they protect children, assuring that the child will never be stranded or outside of the watchful parental gaze. If a car breaks down, one no longer needs to risk getting a ride from a stranger, a risk which is primarily having to confront the overwhelming alienation of our community.

The cell phone constantly bombards the user with updates. It is simpler than having to risk making mundane choices yourself. The user is never difficult to contact about anything, no matter how banal.

The cell phone fulfills the need to be hip and current. Those without mobile communications devices are constucted as being outdated, in the cultural lag, backwards. By owning a cell phone one can feel progressive and up to date.

The underlying motivations for cell phone ownership are fear and convenience. Ultimately fear avoidance and convenience are the same thing – the avoidance of ambiguous situations.

It is no extreme statement to say that capitalism creates false needs. Fifteen years ago cell phones were a rarity, certainly no necessity. How did we live before? They are now a need. We need it like a fix of cellular smack.

It is now standard at many jobs, even low paying ones, to expect ownership of a mobile phone. Employers can constantly contact employees. Labor engulfs everyday life.

Due to the addition of text messaging the cellular communication is trapped between orality and literacy. It has neither the improvisation and open ended nature of spoken language, nor the complexity and depth of written language.

This contributes to a poverty of language. The exchange is constant, yet nearly meaningless. This poverty of language contributes to a poverty of thought.

The E911 system, required by law to be included on all cell phones, allows the location of any cell phone to be triangulated, via GPS, within a few yards. The communication device becomes a tracking device. The cell is a cell.

Paranoid? Maybe. After all, they can’t be tracking everybody all the time, there are just too many people. Precisely the point. The E911 system fulfills the concept of the Panopticon analyzed by Michel Foucault. We know they can’t be paying attention to everyone at every given moment. At the same time we know that they have the capability for surveillance on anyone at any given time.

This position causes the internalization of the control of surveillance. The oppressor is no longer a clear external force, it is now a formless totality which impersonally constrains us. This formlessness makes it difficult to remain autonomous against it, it can not be pinned down. Furthermore, the user knows that they consented.

Cellular technology is transforming human beings into cyborgs. The technology grows more ever-present. The user becomes more and more integrated into the totality. McLuhan argued that the integrated circuit and the television were extensions of the nervous system. He seems to have been premature. The cell phone is closer to the realization of this extension of the neurological system. Remember McLuhan’s often forgotten companion point – every extension is also an amputation.

The cell phone is becoming a permanent extension. It is responded to nearly automatically. This interaction forms a feedback system – a cybernetic system. What thoughts are ours, in this cybernetic system? This cybernetic transformation is particularly noticeable in the case of earpieces and other hands free devices.

The question this brings up is not one of right and wrong. It is a matter of admitting that these devices cause major shifts and determining if these shifts are what we actually want. It has been pointed out to me that the picture I present may even be too optimistic. As for my participation in these shifts, personally, I refuse and resist.